Get your Closed Captioning/Subtitle Options ready; The Pirates of Penzance is here to confuse, confound and delight a certain sector of Broadway intelligentsia. The much-lauded Gilbert and Sullivan musical-comedy opera, which was such a huge revival hit in the early 1980s, Universal decided to make it into a “feature film” with the entire cast (sans one major addition). Is more a film that one respects for the daredevil verbal acrobatics of the musical performers than it is an actual jolly (roger) good time at the (movie) theater.
The 150-year-old story of young love, misread contracts, and pirates is as dusty as it was probably in 1870 when it was first produced. Seemingly inspired in part by Romeo and Juliet, the Gilbert and Sullivan opera demands your attention at every moment. Not for its detailed insights into the human condition, but because the alliterations come so quickly and the vernacular is so archaic that one needs to be at the top of their game mentally to understand the proceedings. The musical itself lays so much plot into the songs themselves; if one isn’t paying attention, one will be lost.
The thrill and entertainment of watching The Pirates of Penzance is in the performances themselves. The way that the cast is so able to nimbly approach the verbal tangled knots of lyrics the opera presents is truly breathtaking. Kevin Kline, Angela Lansbury, Rex Smith, Linda Ronstadt, and George Rose all take on the mountain of a play that makes one wish they were back in 1980 New York to see them all (minus Lansbury, who was added to the film cast when Estelle Parsons dropped out) perform this live. Though Kline (playing the Pirate King) and Lansbury, as expected, show why they were such respected stars of stage and screen, it’s George Rose as the father of seven and the Major-General who protects Panzance with the standout performance. Rose’s rendition of the showstopper I Am the Very Model of a Modern Major-General would give Busta Rhymes in his Prime a dizzy spell. That performance alone, with its confusing patter, is worthy of admission.
The Pirates of Penzance’s biggest problem is that there is no gusto or verve to the adaptation by writer/director Wilford Leach. The artifice of the sets is fine and can be dealt with, but everything is flat without any sort of inspired direction or style to the piece to match the performances. The same goes for the staging and musical numbers. There isn’t a moment where one doesn’t feel the “stage bound” nature of the piece. The result is a film that feels stagnant and laborious even if the performances are filled with exuberance.
The Transfer
The all-new HDR/Dolby Vision Master – From a 4K Scan of the 35mm Original Camera Negative is another excellent edition to Kino’s Library of cult titles. Regardless of this reviewer’s thoughts on the stagnant direction, the glossy widescreen image photographed by Douglas Slocombe looks stunning on this new 4K UHD disc. There isn’t a scratch or issue throughout the runtime of the film. The Dolby Vision/HDR mastering gives depth to the black levels and contrast that just can’t be accomplished with SDR mastering, allowing for a much more detailed, luminous, subtle image.
The Extras
They include the following;
DISC 1 (4KUHD):
NEW Audio Commentary by Film Historian/Writer Julie Kirgo and Writer/Filmmaker Peter Hankoff
DISC 2 (BLU-RAY):
NEW Audio Commentary by Film Historian/Writer Julie Kirgo and Writer/Filmmaker Peter Hankoff
Follow the Art: Interview with Actor Rex Smith
Theatrical Trailer
The all-new Audio Commentary by Film Historian/Writer Julie Kirgo and Writer/Filmmaker Peter Hankoff begins with the duo’s credentials before diving into the film. Some of the details include the unique opening for the film with an overture of sorts like a theater production; the origins of this film adaptation that begins with producer William Pap and how he modernized the Gilbert and Sullivan opera casting popstars Rex Smith and Linda Ronstadt; the use of the original Broadway cast recording and how they lip sync’d and did not record live on set; the reviews of the Broadway opera – including notorious fickle Frank Rich’s rave review; the film’s focus on Ronstadt and Smith rather than Kline’s Pirate King which the show is primary’s focus; the production details like budget, scheduling, and its dual release in theaters and on HBO; the history of piracy and Penzance during the era that the opera takes place; the history of Shakespeare in the Park and its progenitor, producer Joseph Papp – which this version of the opera premiered at; this history of Pirate movies that this film is a part of; a discussion of career and work of star Kevin Kline – including his work in both film and theater; a larger discussion of the work Gilbert and Sullivan; a larger discussion of the musical career and talents of Linda Ronstadt; and much more.
Follow the Art: Interview with Actor Rex Smith (59:39) – in this all-new interview with the actor begins with where he was in his career when he got the role of Fredric in the Broadway production of The Pirates of Penzance. Smith goes on to discuss the version of the production that played Shakespeare in the Park; a great story about Kevin Kline and the beginning of their friendship; working with Linda Ronstadt; the success of the Broadway production and moving over to the film adaptation in England; stories from the film production that include some great anecdotes about Kline, Angela Lansbury, Christopher Reeve, and more; how Francis Ford Coppola was originally set to direct; and much more.
Rounding out the special features are trailers for The Pirates of Penzance (2:27); Jesus Christ Superstar (1:09); Thoroughly Modern Millie (2:39); Can’t Stop the Music (2:58); Xanadu (2:05); Zoot Suit (2:17); Cry-Baby (1:58); In & Out (2:32); Cry Freedom (2:43); The January Man (1:29); Death on the Nile (2:51);
The Final Thought
Kino gives us another stellar 4K UHD upgrade with The Pirates of Penzance.
Pirates and Opera? Kevin Kline stars in the musical comedy The Pirates of Penzance. New to 4K UHD from Kino Lorber.
The Film
Get your Closed Captioning/Subtitle Options ready; The Pirates of Penzance is here to confuse, confound and delight a certain sector of Broadway intelligentsia. The much-lauded Gilbert and Sullivan musical-comedy opera, which was such a huge revival hit in the early 1980s, Universal decided to make it into a “feature film” with the entire cast (sans one major addition). Is more a film that one respects for the daredevil verbal acrobatics of the musical performers than it is an actual jolly (roger) good time at the (movie) theater.
The 150-year-old story of young love, misread contracts, and pirates is as dusty as it was probably in 1870 when it was first produced. Seemingly inspired in part by Romeo and Juliet, the Gilbert and Sullivan opera demands your attention at every moment. Not for its detailed insights into the human condition, but because the alliterations come so quickly and the vernacular is so archaic that one needs to be at the top of their game mentally to understand the proceedings. The musical itself lays so much plot into the songs themselves; if one isn’t paying attention, one will be lost.
The thrill and entertainment of watching The Pirates of Penzance is in the performances themselves. The way that the cast is so able to nimbly approach the verbal tangled knots of lyrics the opera presents is truly breathtaking. Kevin Kline, Angela Lansbury, Rex Smith, Linda Ronstadt, and George Rose all take on the mountain of a play that makes one wish they were back in 1980 New York to see them all (minus Lansbury, who was added to the film cast when Estelle Parsons dropped out) perform this live. Though Kline (playing the Pirate King) and Lansbury, as expected, show why they were such respected stars of stage and screen, it’s George Rose as the father of seven and the Major-General who protects Panzance with the standout performance. Rose’s rendition of the showstopper I Am the Very Model of a Modern Major-General would give Busta Rhymes in his Prime a dizzy spell. That performance alone, with its confusing patter, is worthy of admission.
The Pirates of Penzance’s biggest problem is that there is no gusto or verve to the adaptation by writer/director Wilford Leach. The artifice of the sets is fine and can be dealt with, but everything is flat without any sort of inspired direction or style to the piece to match the performances. The same goes for the staging and musical numbers. There isn’t a moment where one doesn’t feel the “stage bound” nature of the piece. The result is a film that feels stagnant and laborious even if the performances are filled with exuberance.
The Transfer
The all-new HDR/Dolby Vision Master – From a 4K Scan of the 35mm Original Camera Negative is another excellent edition to Kino’s Library of cult titles. Regardless of this reviewer’s thoughts on the stagnant direction, the glossy widescreen image photographed by Douglas Slocombe looks stunning on this new 4K UHD disc. There isn’t a scratch or issue throughout the runtime of the film. The Dolby Vision/HDR mastering gives depth to the black levels and contrast that just can’t be accomplished with SDR mastering, allowing for a much more detailed, luminous, subtle image.
The Extras
They include the following;
DISC 1 (4KUHD):
DISC 2 (BLU-RAY):
The all-new Audio Commentary by Film Historian/Writer Julie Kirgo and Writer/Filmmaker Peter Hankoff begins with the duo’s credentials before diving into the film. Some of the details include the unique opening for the film with an overture of sorts like a theater production; the origins of this film adaptation that begins with producer William Pap and how he modernized the Gilbert and Sullivan opera casting popstars Rex Smith and Linda Ronstadt; the use of the original Broadway cast recording and how they lip sync’d and did not record live on set; the reviews of the Broadway opera – including notorious fickle Frank Rich’s rave review; the film’s focus on Ronstadt and Smith rather than Kline’s Pirate King which the show is primary’s focus; the production details like budget, scheduling, and its dual release in theaters and on HBO; the history of piracy and Penzance during the era that the opera takes place; the history of Shakespeare in the Park and its progenitor, producer Joseph Papp – which this version of the opera premiered at; this history of Pirate movies that this film is a part of; a discussion of career and work of star Kevin Kline – including his work in both film and theater; a larger discussion of the work Gilbert and Sullivan; a larger discussion of the musical career and talents of Linda Ronstadt; and much more.
Follow the Art: Interview with Actor Rex Smith (59:39) – in this all-new interview with the actor begins with where he was in his career when he got the role of Fredric in the Broadway production of The Pirates of Penzance. Smith goes on to discuss the version of the production that played Shakespeare in the Park; a great story about Kevin Kline and the beginning of their friendship; working with Linda Ronstadt; the success of the Broadway production and moving over to the film adaptation in England; stories from the film production that include some great anecdotes about Kline, Angela Lansbury, Christopher Reeve, and more; how Francis Ford Coppola was originally set to direct; and much more.
Rounding out the special features are trailers for The Pirates of Penzance (2:27); Jesus Christ Superstar (1:09); Thoroughly Modern Millie (2:39); Can’t Stop the Music (2:58); Xanadu (2:05); Zoot Suit (2:17); Cry-Baby (1:58); In & Out (2:32); Cry Freedom (2:43); The January Man (1:29); Death on the Nile (2:51);
The Final Thought
Kino gives us another stellar 4K UHD upgrade with The Pirates of Penzance.
Kino Lorber’s 4K UHD Edition of The Pirates of Penzance is out now.
Share this:
Like this:
Discover more from The Movie Isle
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.